Why Matt Carpenter’s Production Is Misleading (and Complicated) – FanGraphs

There are two hitters I would like to introduce. The first, Player A, has been described in terms of the classic trio of statistics: average, on-base percentage, and slugging. The second, Player B, has been described in terms of modern metrics like Exit Velocity and Barrel rate. Take a look at their numbers and try to see who’s better:

Player A: .081/.205/.162

Player B: 95.4 mph Exit Velocity, 63.6% Hard-Hit rate, 27.3% Barrel rate

Not much of a competition, right? Without additional context, you probably chose Player B in a heartbeat. Player A’s appalling triple-slash makes him a DFA candidate. Player B, on the other hand, looks like a hitting genius! Those numbers and rates would place him well above the 95th percentile of all major leaguers. The twist, of course, is that these two hitters are in fact the same person: Matt Carpenter, veteran infielder for the St. Louis Cardinals.

Traditional and modern metrics do disagree at times, but the disparity between them is seldom this wide. Through 18 games, Carpenter’s efforts to clobber the ball have not translated into actual results, much to the chagrin of Cardinals fans. There’s having a stretch of bad luck, then there’s hitting below .100. Is there something else we’re missing?

Let’s investigate and find out. Already, there’s a glaring problem with Carpenter’s production. While his numbers on contact are excellent, he hasn’t been making regular contact. His K% and Whiff% rank in the fifth and 10th percentiles, respectively. Baseball Savant’s metrics, which are calculated on a per BBE (batted ball event) basis, don’t reflect those issues. As a demonstration, I determined Carpenter’s Barrel and Hard-Hit rates based on his per PA results instead. Doing so casts him in a less flattering light:

Statcast Metrics, BBE vs. PA

Metric per BBE per PA
Barrel% 27.3% 13.6%
Hard-Hit% 63.6% 32.6%

SOURCE: Baseball Savant

These new rates wouldn’t look so salient on a Baseball Savant page. For a hitter who’s whiffing often, a change in the denominator has an outsized effect on how he’s portrayed. Carpenter has 22 batted balls as opposed to 44 plate appearances, 16 of which ended in a strikeout. That doesn’t necessarily mean we should switch to per PA metrics – whiff and strikeout numbers are easily accessible – but it’s easy to ignore the negatives and focus on the positive, especially as fans.

But sure, the fact remains that Carpenter has hit six barrels. Of the 336 hitters to record at least one, only 37 have more than six. His achievement is nothing to sneeze at. The fact also remains that those six barrels have resulted in a single hit (a home run, at least) and five outs. Probability-wise, it seems bonkers. There’s another caveat, though, which provides insight into why it’s still bonkers, but not as bonkers as you might think. That begins by reviewing the definition of a “Barrel.” Here’s a succinct one straight from the source:

“To be Barreled, a batted ball requires an exit velocity of at least 98 mph. At that speed, balls struck with a launch angle between 26-30 degrees always garner Barreled classification. For every mph over 98, the range of launch angles expands.”

Reading this unlocks a key observation: Not all barrels are created equal. It’s a cliche within the sabermetric community, but it’s true nonetheless. A 98 mph, 30-degree batted ball receives the same classification as a 115 mph, 30-degree rocket. For example, this mammoth Shohei Ohtani blast is a barrel:

But so is this Matt Carpenter fly out:

You can see where I’m going here. When Carpenter has managed to make contact this season, even his best instances have been relatively lackluster. Here’s how they’ve looked so far, according to a few important metrics:

Matt Carpenter’s Barrels of 2021

Date EV (mph) LA (deg) xwOBA
4/21/21 101 26 1.274
4/16/21 99.8 33 .965
4/13/21 106.9 40 1.189
4/11/21 98.5 26 .993
4/8/21 106.6 38 1.432
4/6/21 101.4 30 1.310

SOURCE: Baseball Savant

Carpenter’s barrels are those kids who barely pass the height requirement for a roller coaster ride. None of them are above 110 mph. Two of them are above 36 degrees, at which point it’s difficult to be productive, but they’re classified as barrels because of their exit velocities. Still, by xwOBA, these are some of the best outcomes a hitter can muster. So why is Carpenter not reaping the benefits?

Let’s consider the other four barrels that were hit under 36 degrees. They’re situated in the optimal launch angle range, at least – wOBA by launch angle tends to peak around 25 degrees, then tails off to the left or right of that mark. But what isn’t mentioned as often is that the optimal launch angle for a hitter changes depending on his Max EV, a measure of raw power. Courtesy of Connor Kurcon, below is a comparison between hitters whose Max EVs are below 110 mph and hitters whose Max EVs are above that mark:

For hitters who possess middling raw power, the sweet spot that exists in the 20 to 30-degree range is significantly diminished. Their best bet is to thrive on line drives, which are equally beneficial for both groups. Carpenter isn’t just unlucky; he’s also hitting the types of fly ball barrels that are unsuited to his skills. That only makes it harder to achieve consistent success.

His misfortune doesn’t end here, though. Earlier this month, Ben Clemens and I each took a preliminary dive into the new official baseball. We didn’t arrive at a concrete answer, but we did note that the distance on batted balls between 25 and 40 degrees had decreased. Guess whose barrels all fall within that range? With a different baseball, some of Carpenter’s barrels might have cleared the fence or sailed over the heads of outfielders, but alas, he picked the wrong time to experience a power surge.

What about his other, non-barreled hard-hit balls? One of them, a scorching 101.1 mph ground ball, resulted in one of his three hits. That’s good! The rest, however, are an assortment of less successful grounders and weaker versions of his fly ball barrels. There’s a lone line drive. Again, as with barrels, the story repeats itself – 63.6% are hard-hit by definition, but come with several flaws, whether they are insufficient exit velocities or awkward launch angles.

I’ve focused a ton on the negatives, but in the end, Carpenter’s weird production seems like it comes down to equal parts rotten luck and batted ball mishaps. With how often he’s striking out – his K% has been climbing since 2016 – it’s unlikely he’ll catch up to his .369 xwOBA. It’s also unlikely that he’ll remain at his actual wOBA of .171. As the sample size becomes more robust, they’ll meet somewhere in the middle. But maybe there’s a reason to lean optimistic. I borrowed a page from Devan Fink’s book and scraped data from 2019, the previous “regular” season, and looked at how well a hitter’s Barrel% from April correlated to his Barrel% across the entire season. The metric is a great descriptor and predictor of offensive success, and it’s Carpenter’s that stands out. Yes, it’ll go down, but maybe traces of it will remain:

April Barrel vs Full Season Barrel ProxyEgg Why Matt Carpenter's Production Is Misleading (and Complicated) - FanGraphs

Not bad! Hitters seem to retain way more of their early-season rate than I thought. Now, this is a heinous use of statistics that should never be replicated in a formal setting, but for fun, I plugged in Carpenter’s 2021 Barrel rate into the formula for the regression line. The result: 17.9%, which would represent the highest rate of his career in the Statcast era. There’s a near-zero chance he sustains a Trout-esque mark for an entire season, of course, but the bottom line is that April numbers aren’t totally meaningless. It’s downhill from there, but that’s not as bad as it sounds.

Overall, it’s a bit complicated. Matt Carpenter’s gaudy Statcast numbers are misleading due to his poor contact rates and inability to generate line drives thus far, which benefit him the most. Instead, myriad fly balls aren’t traveling like they used to, or don’t have enough speed behind them. At the same time, you can’t just ignore what Carpenter has accomplished. His shortcomings are still elite by major league standards. Ultimately, a sample of 22 batted balls just isn’t enough, and only time will tell whether the veteran slugger will follow a downward trend that began in 2019, resurge to his former level of play, or even unlock the next step in his career.

Source of this news: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/why-matt-carpenters-production-is-misleading-and-complicated/

Related posts:

The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence and The Importance of Transdisciplinary Research - BBN Tim...
Will humans worship artificial intelligence (AI) in the near future?  In less than two decades, machines have outclassed humans.  The development of full artificial intelligence could spe...
Saturday Night Live Recap: Nick Jonas Dreams of Post-COVID Life - Vulture
Saturday Night Live Nick Jonas Season 46 Episode 14 Editor’s Rating 3 stars *** Photo: NBC/Will Heath/NBC Though still primarily known as a pop star and one of the (reuni...
Workplace tools for Brokers Adds See and Futures Trading Underpin Powered by Binance exactly what yo...
Workplace tools For Brokers (TFB), a foreign FX technology company, delivers announced on Monday that the cord has added support for position and futures trading electric by Binance, a cryptocur...
VPN vs proxy: what's the difference and which should you get? - Tom's Guide
If you’re looking to change your location online and stay a little more private, you may be wondering which is better when it comes to comparing VPN and proxy servers. For the casual user, it mi...
Whistleblower: Ubiquiti Breach “Catastrophic” – Krebs on Security - Krebs on Security
On Jan. 11, Ubiquiti Inc. [NYSE:UI] — a major vendor of cloud-enabled Internet of Things (IoT) devices such as routers, network video recorders and security cameras — disclosed that a breach involvin...
Deutsche Bank AG (DB) Q3 2021 Earnings Call Transcript - The Motley Fool
Image source: The Motley Fool. Deutsche Bank AG (NYSE:DB)Q3 2021 Earnings CallOct 27, 2021, 7:00 a.m. ETContents: Prepared Remarks Questions and Answers Call Participants Prepared Rema...
Fix League of Legends Error Code 003 on Windows PC - TheWindowsClub
If you are getting the League of Legends error 003 on your Windows 11 or Windows 10 gaming PC, then this post is intended to help you with the most suitable solutions to fix the error. This error usu...
Shelter Your IP Address and Waters Anonymously with Web Proxy server - Wales 247
The question of roa safety on the internet is quite important in this modern day. Every time you surf the Net, websites are hands down collecting your data, based on your amazing IP address. Firs...
'Neurevt' Trojan Targets Mexican Banking concern Customers - BankInfoSecurity. apresentando
Account Takeover Fraud , Cybercrime , Fraud Remedies & Cybercrime Updated Malware This time Includes Spyware and a Backdoor Prajeet Nair ( @prajeetspeaks ) • June 19, 2021 &nbs...
authID.ai to Hold Annual Meeting on December 29, 2021 - KULR-TV
LONG BEACH, NY , Nov. 23, 2021 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- authID.ai  [Nasdaq: AUID], a leading provider of secure, mobile, biometric authentication solutions, today announced that its 2021 Annual Meet...
You know about 404 error codes, but what the heck is a 503? - CNET
Here's your guide to the sometimes mysterious world of 404s and beyond.  CNET Sure you've seen a 404 error code -- remember Twitter's infamous fail whale? -- but what about a 503? Or a 400 or 3...
Network Server Management: LogicMonitor vs. ManageEngine OpManager | ENP - EnterpriseNetworkingPlane...
A server is a computer or system that is designed to behave as a repository and provide computing resources, services, data and programs to other computers (clients) connected to the network. Technic...
Using DW and Psiphon to circumvent internet censorship - Deutsche Welle
One of the main missions of DW is to advocate for freedom of expression and free access to information around the world. One of the growing threats to these tenets is internet censorship. Countries a...
Private Proxy Software Adds 10 New Servers with Static IP Addresses - PR Web
Internet privacy can be protected by using an Anonymous Proxy. Past News ReleasesRSS Tampa, Florida (PRWEB) October 13, 2010 Privacy Partners, LLC the developer of Private Proxy Software, an...
How Acunetix addresses HTTP/2 vulnerabilities - Security Boulevard
In the latest release of Acunetix, we added support for the HTTP/2 protocol and introduced several checks specific to the vulnerabilities associated with this protocol. For example, we introduced c...
5 Reasons Your Company Should Use Proxy Servers - CMSWire
The average person probably has only a vague understanding of the purpose of a proxy server. If you’re like most people, you probably associate proxy servers with unblocking Netflix content from ...
Maryland businessman bids $650 million for all of Tribune, including The Baltimore Sun - Baltimore S...
Bainum subsequently made his bid for the whole company on March 16, Tribune Publishing said in the SEC filing. In addition to Baltimore Sun Media, which includes the Capital Gazette in Annapolis, Ca...
The best free VPN for Chrome - PCWorld
Best free VPN for Chrome | PCWorld Skip to content <!-- --> Google If you have a Chromebook or don’t want yet another prog...

IP Rotating Proxy Onsale

SPECIAL LIMITED TIME OFFER

00
Months
00
Days
00
Hours
00
Minutes
00
Seconds
First month free with coupon code FREE30